• Projects Right
  • Posts
  • đźš©Why “checking the box” kills your project

🚩Why “checking the box” kills your project

Checklist culture looks productive—but it hides the real problems. Here’s what to do instead.

In partnership with

Thank you to our sponsors for making this newsletter free to everyone!

Start learning AI in 2025

Everyone talks about AI, but no one has the time to learn it. So, we found the easiest way to learn AI in as little time as possible: The Rundown AI.

It's a free AI newsletter that keeps you up-to-date on the latest AI news, and teaches you how to apply it in just 5 minutes a day.

Plus, complete the quiz after signing up and they’ll recommend the best AI tools, guides, and courses – tailored to your needs.

WHY THIS MATTERS

Too many projects fail even when every box is checked.

Teams follow the plan, tasks get marked “complete,” and status updates sound positive. But when the final product is delivered, it misses the mark.

Stakeholders are disappointed, outcomes fall short, and no one can pinpoint what went wrong—because technically, nothing did.

This is the danger of checklist culture: it creates the illusion of progress while letting real impact slip through the cracks.

BEFORE WE GET STARTED

🚨 Have you accessed my Project Management Masterclass?

If not, you’re missing out on:

  • 4+ hours of expert-led, on-demand video training – practical, actionable, and built for busy professionals.

  • You can use 250+ plug-and-play templates & Excel trackers â€“ real-world tools immediately.

  • AI-driven strategies & data-backed decision-making – master cutting-edge project management techniques that give you a competitive edge.

  • Lifetime access with monthly course updates – stay ahead without additional costs. Purchase this one time and get all future courses added!

  • Interview mastery training – land high-paying roles with confidence.

THE METHOD

Checklist culture is comfortable.
It looks like progress.
But it often leads to mediocre results.

Here’s how to shift from checking boxes to driving real outcomes:

  1. Redefine “Done”
    → Replace vague tasks with clear definitions of success
    → Align task completion with actual business outcomes
    → Ask: “If we finish this, how will we know it worked?”

Example Action: Take one deliverable today and add a note that defines what success looks like for the user.

  1. Get Closer to the Problem
    → Talk to end users early—not just stakeholders
    → Understand what’s really broken or needs solving
    → Cut anything that doesn’t support the core issue

Example Action: DM one end user or customer-facing team member and ask, “What’s been frustrating you lately with this system/process?”

  1. Design for Impact, Not Activity
    → Build backwards from the result you want
    → Skip unnecessary steps—optimize for outcomes
    → Make it normal to remove tasks if they don’t add value

Example Action: Look at your task list today. Cross out one item that no longer serves a real purpose.

  1. Make Feedback the Default
    → Don’t wait until the end to check if it worked
    → Create 2-3 checkpoints during the project for alignment
    → Invite challenge, not just confirmation

Example Action: Schedule a midpoint feedback session for your current project with the question, “Is this solving the right problem?”

  1. Ditch Perfection, Deliver Early
    → Focus on delivering a version that works—not one that’s flawless
    → Learn faster by shipping faster
    → Iterate with real data, not internal opinions

Example Action: Identify one project deliverable you can release a week earlier—even if it’s imperfect.

  1. Teach the Team to Think, Not Just Do
    → Help your team understand why the work matters
    → Encourage questioning the process, not just following it
    → Reward insights, not just execution

Example Action: Ask one team member today, “What’s one task you feel we’re doing just because it’s on the list?”

  1. Measure What Matters
    → Track outcomes, not hours spent or steps completed
    → Focus your metrics on what moved the needle
    → Kill vanity KPIs that don’t reflect real progress

Example Action: Replace one of your team’s “activity-based” metrics with an outcome-focused one.

  1. Debrief for Outcomes
    → At project close, ask: “What did we actually change?”
    → Capture wins and misfires to build smarter systems
    → Create a short recap that highlights real-world impact

Example Action: For your last project, write a 3-bullet debrief focused only on what changed for the user, customer, or business.

CLOSING THOUGHTS

Checklists aren’t the enemy—but they’re not the destination, either.

They’re tools.

Use them wisely, but don’t let them replace judgment.

Great project managers don’t just get things done—they make sure what gets done actually matters.

The goal isn’t to look organized. It’s to deliver results that last.

THAT’S A WRAP

Here’s how I can help you:

  1. Project Management Online Masterclass: This 4+ hour video training is your shortcut to leading projects with clarity, cutting through the noise, and positioning yourself as the go-to expert.

  2. AI-Enhanced Project Management Live Cohort: Build an AI-enhanced project management work portfolio and become an outcome-first, people-focused PM built for real leadership. Prior enrollment is available through April 15th.

  3. Corporate Training, Private Cohorts, and Workshops: Wait to unlock your team’s true potential? Schedule a complimentary introductory chat, and let's see if we are a good fit to work together to offer project management training to your team.

Until next time,
Justin